Curse

Redwinter · Jan 31, 2007, 09:54 PM // 21:54

Yeah. In-game PvE (or even PvP) buffs are ridiculously stupid and against the spirit of the game.

I'd like to see:

Drunkard: While this title is checked off, you are slightly drunk. This title does not help you gain further ranks in this title track.
Incorrigible Ale-Hound: While this title is checked off, you are excessively drunk.
Cartographer of [Campaign]: For each rank in this title, you move 4% faster while in a town of [Campaign]. (ie. Canthan Cartographer = faster in all Cantha towns). This does not stack with Sugar Rush.

Evilsod · Feb 01, 2007, 12:21 AM // 00:21

Quote:

Originally Posted by Redwinter

Yeah. In-game PvE (or even PvP) buffs are ridiculously stupid and against the spirit of the game.

I'd like to see:

Drunkard: While this title is checked off, you are slightly drunk. This title does not help you gain further ranks in this title track.
Incorrigible Ale-Hound: While this title is checked off, you are excessively drunk.
Cartographer of [Campaign]: For each rank in this title, you move 4% faster while in a town of [Campaign]. (ie. Canthan Cartographer = faster in all Cantha towns). This does not stack with Sugar Rush.

Ok, now these ideas i like.

King Kong Monkey · Feb 03, 2007, 05:08 PM // 17:08

I really love to see an emote for the other PvP titles like Gladiator and Champion, not only Hero. With other animals or whatever and anohter collor.
What is your opinion about that?

Cherrie · Feb 03, 2007, 05:14 PM // 17:14

/notsigned to anything that influences the gameplay. Including the benefits already present in-game.

GW policy used to not benefid hardcore-players over casual players. No matter how long you played, you had same chances everywhere etc etc. Only differences present were aestetical ones - and this was great. I'd like GW to stay that way, that's why I'm against any benefits gained from titles apart from auras etc.

Fred Kiwi · Feb 03, 2007, 05:16 PM // 17:16

Quote:

Originally Posted by Cherrie

/notsigned to anything that influences the gameplay. Including the benefits already present in-game.

GW policy used to not benefid hardcore-players over casual players. No matter how long you played, you had same chances everywhere etc etc. Only differences present were aestetical ones - and this was great. I'd like GW to stay that way, that's why I'm against any benefits gained from titles apart from auras etc.

i think someone needs to have a little re-read

Aeon_Xin · Feb 03, 2007, 05:34 PM // 17:34

Quote:

Originally Posted by Redwinter

Yeah. In-game PvE (or even PvP) buffs are ridiculously stupid and against the spirit of the game.

I'd like to see:

Drunkard: While this title is checked off, you are slightly drunk. This title does not help you gain further ranks in this title track.
Incorrigible Ale-Hound: While this title is checked off, you are excessively drunk.
Cartographer of [Campaign]: For each rank in this title, you move 4% faster while in a town of [Campaign]. (ie. Canthan Cartographer = faster in all Cantha towns). This does not stack with Sugar Rush.

I like my drunk title, but I wouldn't like to always have a wavy screen, and don't think I should have to turn down my graphics because I achieved it.

Cartographers could use that to their benifit, even in a town, they'd have an upper hand delivering christmas presents, for example. That's something that's supposed to be equal among everyone, a chance for noobs to do something. Same reason snowball fights are equalized acrost the board.

MithranArkanere · Feb 03, 2007, 06:06 PM // 18:06

Here's a good one:

For the Big deal, allow the user to show one more title for each level of this title.

So, a Kind Of A Big Deal will be able to select 2 titles to show, and a People Know Me would be able to select 3.

max gladius · Feb 16, 2007, 08:07 PM // 20:07

Skill hunter, per each lvl of it, skills cost 5% less... GOD THAT WOULD BE AWSOME!!!! 1k each gets old real fast!

lvl 1. Kind of Big deal title cause +5% more dmg or something would be awsome, lightbringer title does that against certain enimies,
then lvl 2 People know me, recieve -5% dmg

Running in cities would be cool, but not take the travel speed as high as he recommends... bean cakes and such already cause 20% faster or so...

Mapping titles should give a bonus, if i have mapped 100% of the continent, i feel i should have some heads up on what is where (ie bosses, chests)... not like i haven't been in that area before

Lucky title... for each lvl of it, u get 2% more chance at gold item from chest...

I feel incorporating titles to actual game will bring more ppl to get titles.. Sure seems to work with lightbringer title...

sorry almost forgot the best line in GW... execpt in PVP areas!

/signed

Chewbacca Defense · Feb 16, 2007, 08:22 PM // 20:22

/signed only if effects stay within towns.

Mathias Deathwater · Feb 16, 2007, 09:10 PM // 21:10

I think that the ideas for title bonuses are awesome, just not the ones that have an effect on gameplay, for reasons that you can find elsewhere in this thread. I do think it would be cool if all of the titles had minor bonuses though, like faster running in town, lower skill prices, and the like. Basically:

YES
-Minor monetary bonuses (lower skill prices, better chance to not destroy a salvaged weapon, etc.)
-auras, emotes, the like
-Fun bonuses in town (faster movement speed, maybe access to a special party area in main towns)

NO
-Anything that gives your character a bonus to combat performance (more hp, armor, run speed, cast speed, etc.)

I already think that the lightbringer/sunspear idea is a slippery slope, but it's fine if it stays the way it is, with bonuses against a specific thing, and that's it. I'm just afraid of where this could lead, because if there are too many bonuses against too many things, it would be too much like Lord of the Rings Online's Trait system, where you have to grind various things to get bonuses to your character.

bilateralrope · Feb 16, 2007, 11:03 PM // 23:03

I'm in support of the following benefits for titles:

- Increase speed in town, except during events to keep them fair.
- New emotes for titles.
- Mini-pets for titles, you can spawn the mini at any time you have the title, but its customized for you. As long as we keep the current mini pet limits this shouldn't cause more problems than we already have.
- Access to weapon/armor skins not obtainable otherwise.
- Increased storage limits for faction, gold and item storage. But not for the inventory you carry on your character, especially that gold amount, as it does have an effect on gameplay as the gold limit effects prices and inventory limit effects how much loot you can haul in one run.
- Allowing a player with one of the Faction Allegiance ranks to use their NPCs while having a higher amount of the other sides faction, higher levels means you can have a higher difference.
- Reducing the faction cost of PvP unlocks and getting amber/jadite.
- Allowing people to contribute smaller faction amounts to their alliance, as long as the ratio of faction donated : faction received by alliance remains 1:1. Not that I see anyone using this benefit if they get it.
- Any benefit that only changes your characters looks.
- Unfogging the map for your other characters based on what your cartographer has explored, but any map one of your characters hasn't explored themselves won't count for their cartographer title.

I will not support NPC discounts because they are reducing the capability of gold sinks. However I will not oppose them either.

I will oppose any rewards that give any actual benefit in PvP or PvE no matter how small, this includes the Wisdom, Treasure Hunter, Lightbringer and Sunspear titles.

holababe · Feb 16, 2007, 11:43 PM // 23:43

With the Introduction of the new 'Sweet Tooth' title:

Rank 1 - When in a town you move 25% faster due to a Sugar Rush
Rank 2 - When in a town you move 50% faster due to a Sugar Overdose

DarkCloudInc · Feb 26, 2007, 08:50 AM // 08:50

As late as it is...
/signed for the luxon/kurzick faction point increase holding

/notsigned for the luxon/kurzick faction bonus faction gained
The reason for this is simply that it would encourage guilds to "hire" people to faction farm for their guilds. That would be very detrimental to the game play.

I would like to see the reward for the skill hunter title as the following: For each level gained, purchasing skills from the skills npc is reduced by 50 gold.

Now that would be more than fair.

Hamanaqua · Mar 07, 2007, 07:18 PM // 19:18

Quote:

Originally Posted by Isaac Lunoa

No... Then it would be pretty much required to grind for every title on every character. I already don't like that they've added benefits for any titles... They're meant to be a "status symbol" rather than a required grind.

On the other hand, I don't mind emotes/auras. Just nothing statistically beneficial.

I disagree wholeheartedly. Status Symbol? Seriously? They are status symbols that other gamers/players bear no respect for because so many characters have them. The two hollowest aspects of the game are titles and being an officer. There should absolutely be an intrinsic bonus for gaining a title. A Protector's title means squat to any but the player who gains it. For this reason, that player and the character he dedicated the game play to should benefit from it in a way that enhances the game experience. Someone further back commented on how so much of the game is just for show. I agree and it is my primary issue with Guild Wars (an otherwise fantastic game). NCSoft was SO worried about maintaining balance they practically neutered the idea of having power. Creating skills inherent to class was a good start but they need to allow for greater delineation between characters, their level and their builds. I want to be impressed by how powerful and indestructible a character is. I want to see a title and think “damn, I’d /bow to her”.

This should go for pvp as well as pve. If you get clobbered in pvp because someone has a better built character than you, don’t whine about it; get better. Simple. In pve that is a non issue because of how well GW caters to solo adventuring (creating heroes was a brilliant idea).

Though I have been playing for over a year, I have only one character with the Protector title. Aside from the required ranks within NF, I won't waste my time with getting titles for any others. The work far outweighs the reward. If NCSoft decides to offer tangible bonuses for titles it would give the game a whole new level replay for me.

Ilithis Mithilander · Mar 14, 2007, 12:11 AM // 00:11

I agree with the faction expansion of 2k per title in Luxon and Kurzick respectively.

Neon Ciaren · Mar 14, 2007, 04:44 PM // 16:44

Not sure yet on signing, how about we make this more to where people don't have an advantage in the game by having the title. For Example, Drunkard you can equipt a drunk skill, which can only affect you in outposts. Running 5% faster only in outposts if you equiped the skill. Survivor idea is interesting. Just something that won't affect battleplay. I must say no to the skill idea because that would be an advantage in gameplay.

Your Trada Truly · Mar 14, 2007, 06:23 PM // 18:23

/signed
for the various in town and aura/emote ideas (as long as they are NOTHING like the PVP ones) and also for the more moderate PVE ideas ANET would doubtless moderate them even further...

biggest problem with this game is room for character/account achievement. I tend to think ANET was surprised that GW generated a PVE following and so they are figuring it out as they go along. NF and the title rewards was a good 1st step lets keep this moving forward. All respect to casual players but its the hard core gamers that pay the bills and go out and buy collector edition after collector edition and log in for every event and most of the hours besides. Those also happen to be the gamers who smash through new chapters and who are the 1st to max out titles, those gamers with a PKM or two. Anet needs to be allowed to look out for them too, to create some excitement for them after the 2nd week of the new chapter when they have beat the game and are wrapping up titles.

Many people who only play 5 hours or less a week were attracted to this game because after putting in their minimal amount of time no one else in the game is inherently better. This should be preserved and it will be. I am confident that titles will never offer a benefit in PVP. However many of the not so overpowered PVE ideas in this thread are rather nice and would help to keep the attention of some of the more hardcore players which is a fan base it is better for all of us if GW keeps.

Nemo the Capitalist · Apr 10, 2007, 09:59 PM // 21:59

/signs
chest runners and
wisdom identifers need better stats as well
great thread

Mohnzh · Apr 11, 2007, 03:22 PM // 15:22

/signed and notsigned.

Anything that gives a player a statistical advantage (speed, armor, damage, etc.) in game would, as commented before, go totally against what GW is about. But, most of the titles themselves are money sinks, so things like lowering the cost of skills with skill hunter rank doesn't affect the economy. If people go for the rank for that reason, they will blow more money than save. I'm not sure why people think drunks should move faster. Drunks generally move slower irl, except for when they are in a car. Introduce vehicles and then maybe I will accept that. But as long as we walk, drunks should move slower and maybe fall down every few steps. The faction cap would be useful. 10,000 is just way to small eeven to begin with. When you have a quest that requires spending 10,000 faction and that is your cap...? There was a good treasure hunter bonus thread that got closed, but I have yet to see the ideas reposted here. It had to do with not requiring the [alt] button to see treasures and at even higher ranks identifying treasure locations from further away. Emotes are good, minipets are horrible. I can't even move in Kaineg, LA, and Kamadan because of all the minipets using up bandwidth. Extra title displays for the KOABD is a good idea. My favorite idea is having a choice of an armor mod for titles so that ppl can see them without scrolling over your name. I would like to look at titles, but ppl don't stand still long enough for me to see them. Again, no stat effect, just aesthetics. My $.02

tenshi_strife · Apr 11, 2007, 05:33 PM // 17:33

Quote:

Originally Posted by King_of_Eles

(srry if this has idea has already been presented but I searched and didn't find anything on it)

With the addition of nightfall title effects were introduced for some of the titles. This made me wonder why not add title effects for more if not all of the titles. Why should only the ppl that have the wisdom and treasure hunting titles have a benefit while cartography doesn't. If the pvp titles gave an effect couldn't the Kurzick/Luxon titles give an effect.

Here are some suggested benefits for different titles:
YOu can sign or not sign on various ones if you want.

Cartography: Character moves 5% faster per rank of cartography for the continent they have the title for.

Allegience Luxon/Kurzick: 2k extra faction space per rank. OR 5% increase in faction gains per rank.

Skill Hunter: cost of skills is -5%(or 10%) per rank of title.

Drunkard: Not to encourage drunks but, takes one less drink to get drunk per rank.

Edit: (Survivor: None. An emote or Aura.)

Mission completion track: NO current ideas.

KoaBD track: NO current ideas.

Well thats my proposal. THose are just some suggested bonuses for the respective title tracks but it would give more meaning to the titles. All benefits are just related to their use.

ok this has been siad before i do not want titles to give a combat benifit but here are some ideas i had that would make titles useful without ruining balance

Cartography: each rank would reveal a diff thing on map, like chests, boss locations, shrines, npcs ect. so you would want to get cart title but its not something you need.

Allegience Luxon/Kurzick: 2k extra faction space per rank. OR 5% increase in faction gains per rank. i /sign this. nothing pisses me off more than haveing to leave a group to go spend faction....

Skill Hunter: cost of skills is -5%(or 10%) per rank of title. this is also good cause 1k gold is tooooo much, also another benifit could be the % of exp earned per cap, that was suggested before.

Drunkard: lowers the price of alchol that was suggested before would be bad cause then you could buy low and sell high..... no good, how bout for each rank in drunkard you move 25% faster in town while drunk, this does stack with sugar rush, all i can say is drink beer and shopping around town is easy >.<.

Survivor: yes this would be good but you can add a +exp for each monster you kill cause really survivor is a bitch to get, this would make it easier + you dont really need exp after lvl 20 lol.

Mission completion track: um how bout some emotes and whenever your in a town of the place you got title for and turn on title hte npcs yell "ALL HAIL THE SAVIOR OF (location)(yourname)" "oh i love (your name) he is so brave" like when you beat factions and NF lol.

KoaBD track: i like the idea brought up before for more than one title displayed but that would be hard and cluttered how bout you say random quotes from the movie with this title on lol like when your drunk, the higher you get it the more quotes you get.

you also forgot some

Gamer title: how bout you get to have a special emote dance or you say random nerd wuotes lol

Sweet Tooth: sugar rushes last 5% longer for each rank, easy and good.

now that my thoughts on this